Rights, theft, and democracy

“When a legislature decides to steal some of our rights and plans to use police force to accomplish it, what’s the real difference between them and the thief? Darn little! They hide behind the excuse that they’re legislating democratically. The fact they do it by a majority vote has no moral significance whatsoever. Numerical might does not constitute right, no more than a lynch mob can justify its act because a majority participated.” — Hubert Leon “Bill” Richardson, California state senator (1966-1988), author, Founder and Chairman of Gun Owners of America, writing in December 1995.

A republican form of government with democratic principles must be held in check by the natural, God-given rights of the individual citizens. Morally, no majority can vote away the rights of others — that is absolutely contrary to the fundamental concept of human liberty. And to the charter which established the government of a free people.

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Guy Fawkes Night 2025

Mostly we know the story. A Roman Catholic, part of a despised and persecuted religious minority in England in 1605, was involved in The Gunpowder Plot. This operation was supposed to kill the House of Lords and King James I (of England, VI of Scotland) to make way for a Catholic monarch to take power and end the tyranny of the Stuarts and the nobility. Someone ratted the coup out, and on the night of 5 November, Fawkes and 36 barrels of gunpowder in the basement below the assembly room. After torture, he confessed and was executed. He was supposed to be hung, drawn, and quarters, but he broke his neck falling from the gallows.

He was not a republican (that form of English rebel came 40 years later) nor was he a democrat: he believed in monarchy, in accordance with the teaching of Rome at the time. Today, thanks to changing perceptions, movies like V for Vendetta and its use of Guy Fawkes masks (to be copied in hundreds of protests, especially in Anglophile regions), he is seen as a symbol of resistance against government tyranny.

His story, his perceived example, is an important part of British history, especially given the behavior of both monarchs and Parliament (not just Lords but Commons) in the last four+ centuries: the more forceful tyranny of Charles I, the English Civil War and rule by Parliament under the Protectorate, and on down to the present.

Continue reading
Posted in Nathan's Rants | Leave a comment

Civil war ahead in these States?

In October, MSN presented a “thought piece” on line, “Is the US headed for another Civil War?” As is often the case with such stories, the analysis is shallow, filled with the written equivalent of talking heads, and of course starting with a recent Hollywood movie and quickly moving to compare the current and future state of affairs here in the States to the often mis-labeled American Civil War of 1861-65.

As is common, the article made various claims about what is and what not healthy in American politics, and what system(s) of government we have. One talking head spoke of how we are all part of a single political unit. He then pontificated about how “a fundamental piece of a democracy” is settling disputes non-violently.

Oddly, history shows this claim to be wrong. Even limited forms of democracy have time and again been characterized by intense violence and even greater promises and promotion of violently resolving disputes. Does democracy have a “fundamental piece?” Well, a “fundamental principle?” One source claims it is “popular sovereignty.” This is the idea that the authority of the government is derived from the consent of the governed.

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Day 34: Are we dead yet?

We at TPOL are fond of reminding people that this “government shutdown” is not just bogus in many ways (only some of the FedGov is shut down) but not the worst example of Congress refusing to pass a budget and authorize spending.

The worst example? Back in 1876 (yep, the same year as the Black Hills War and the 7th Cavalry lost 262 dead at the Greasy Grass (Little Big Horn). Congress failed to pass the appropriations bill for the US Army (the Department of War) for six months. Soldiers did not get paid for six months. Contractors supplying food (including food on the hoof!) to military posts did not get paid. Officers often paid for food for their troops out of their own pockets – those officers who had savings or other sources of income. Hunting, foraging, and growing their own crops let some troops in various posts survive. Other troops were supported by local civilians, even in the South. (The former Confederate States were still under occupation in the “Reconstruction” in 1876, before the compromise to elect a president ended the occupation.) Or so our publisher was taught by his historian father.

So things like this just don’t seem all that horrific!

Regarding Big Bend and others: Keeping the tourists out of many national parks means that the rangers and other staff are not nearly so important: after all, these areas survived without much human care for thousands of years. Most of what NPS staff have to maintain (and clean up) is due to the tourists and the facilities coddling them.

Congress continues to be a welcome stumbling block for government, even if everything is really not shut down. Mark Twain’s famous quotes about Congress are again proven true:

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Guest commentary, Image of liberty, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The costs of war – and of peace

It seems that the latest plan for peace – or at least a cessation of overt combat – is being implemented in Canaan. All be it with many setbacks and detours. We know what the costs of war have been, and continue to be. But do we understand the costs of peace? Regardless of how close to real peace, and not just another ceasefire and temporary cessation of (most) hostilities, is going to be achieved?

Many are singing the praises of The Donald for negotiating this deal. Of course, many more are screaming in frustration that the Bad Orange Guy has actually lived up to his boasting. At least for now. Several point out that the “leftists” (Regressives) are in a pickle: they’ve been screaming about Israeli genocide of Palestinians (or Gazans, at least) and demanding that the US (and others) stop it. But at what political cost to the Regressives?

But (as expected), many more people also are continuing to condemn The Donald. Both for a bad job and for demanding or promising things that they disagree with. And there are also many who are just ignoring what he and the other negotiators did, and what is going on now.

Of course, we assume after well over a century of Arab-Jewish conflict, and of Western (Brit, French, American) double-dealing and stupidity, this is really peace. Trump is very optimistic – but then, he always is. Most Israelis and many Arabs are also happy. But will it last?

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Pushing free speech – where?

An appeals court has reversed a lower court ruling that a Wisconsin mother defamed a teacher of her children, and the school district, in a social media post in 2022. Calling her “Woke” and sarcastically a “White savior” because of what was being taught and noting that the teacher was also the school’s DEI coordinator was just an opinion and vague enough to not merit a charge of defamation.

Scarlett Johnson, the mom, said the lawsuit was intended to intimidate her and others, especially members of the Wisconsin chapter of Moms for Liberty. We would tend to agree, given that it has taken three years to get to this point.

Although Mrs. Johnson was aided by volunteers, donors, and the MFL organization, most Americans do not have the financial wherewithall to fight such a protracted legal battle. And have to give up, or suffer even more. There is no doubt that just in recent memory, there are thousands of Americans who have chosen not to speak out on matters like this for fear of just this sort of thing.

It is not just government-run schools and DEI advocates and the like who try to intimidate and even punish people for speaking out.

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

NYC and blue states, red states, blue cities, and red cities

Want to think of something scary for Halloween night? Consider the modern American city.

In 2025, the handwriting is clearly on the wall. New York City is evidence of this, if we needed more. Whatever the results of next week’s election, it is clear that the City – and the entire urban area it anchors – is in serious trouble.

Why? We at TPOL submit that this is exactly what we should expect of parasites. Ultimately, most parasites kill their host/victim. And as a result, die themselves. Government and its officials and employees are those parasites on the American body politic. And stupid.

American cities (at least in their present form) are doomed. The more extreme of us would point out, “the sooner, the better.” The vast megalopoli are ungovernable; their economic systems function (barely) in spite of their governance and society; their societies are decadent and decaying ever more rapidly.

And virtually every action taken by governmental bodies adds to (and even speeds up) that process of decay. Even while they proclaim all the wonderful things they are doing. Are going to do. Have done.

Continue reading
Posted in Nathan's Rants | Leave a comment

Is it possible to restore liberty and freedom?

Consider these quotes:

“But a Constitution of Government once changed from Freedom, can never be restored. Liberty, once lost, is lost forever.” – John Adams

 “Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.” – Ronald Reagan

Whatever we may think, looking back decades or centuries, about these men and their actual understanding of liberty, government, and humankind, these quotes are meaningful to lovers of liberty as we near the end of 2025.

Is Adams’ warning correct? Many people today dream of restoring American constitutional government, as originally intended and perceived by Adams and the men and women of his generation. Are they going to be disappointed? Is true restoration possible? Or even a rough imitation of what the original Thirteen States had?

Continue reading
Posted in History of Liberty, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Starting week #5 – some humor, perhaps?

(A BAKER’S DOZEN (TM)) Now we have survived – even thrived! – for four weeks with only “minimum essential” government. How much farther can we go? When will we really see what it is like to have the FedGov really shut down? Are we, should we, heed the warnings about the catastrophe of not having the FedGov “taking care of us?”

Time for a bit of humor. So here is a selection of old WARNING SIGNS from the point of view of lovers of liberty:

Continue reading
Posted in Image of liberty, Nathan's Rants, Short Takes | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Four weeks…

The 28th of October, 2025. The FedGov has been shut down for four weeks. Twenty-eight days.

As we all know, the results are catastrophic. The Fifty States have fallen into anarchy and chaos. Jerusalem in AD 70 and Berlin in AD 1945 are pale fore-shadows of New York, San Francisco, Chicago, and DC. The Germanies in the Thirty Years’ War fared better than the Fifty States.

Continue reading
Posted in Commentary on the News, Fiction, Nathan's Rants | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment